Reinstatement of the Draft. The selective service Essay

Reinstatement of the Draft. The selective service - Essay Example The Rangel proposal is supported by yet another ranking democratic Congressman, and a fellow member of the Congressional Black Caucus; Representative John Conyers (D. Mich.), contend that African Americans and Hispanics are disproportionately represented in today’s military, he says the children of the rich should serve alongside the less privileged Americans in the war on terror† (Conyers) Obviously, it would not be prudent to attack either one of the Congressmen as being racist, for obvious reasons. However, one can safely challenge, whether their altruistic motives are the appropriate panacea for leveling the battle field. We must take with a grain of salt, the suggestions of anyone who advocates the dismantling of the professional force – this entity has been efficient in serving America for more than 30 years. When one questions the experts of military history and science, not to mention 2 those who have conducted scientific studies on the subject, wherein th e overwhelming conclusion is an all volunteer – (professional) military is much more efficient, that there are specific cases of more bravery and they get the job done with far less anomalies and other types of malfeasance than one could ever expect when using draftees. One must be mindful of our recent past with the draft. The Selective Service sometime in 1967, shifted to a lottery in their selection process, ostensibly this shift would add parity and result in less discrimination against the poor and people of color. It is important to note, that the outcome in Vietnam, reflected that the rich and the privileged, did not report to induction centers, as their money and influence served them well in securing exemptions. Ostensibly, the lottery draft was designed to add parity to the process and make the military more representative of the general American Population. However, it was used to widen the gap. According to James Carafano, a 25 year veteran of the armed forces, and a senior fellow at the Heritage foundation, "conscription makes sense only in moments of extreme national peril such as the Civil War and World War II. During the second world war, for example, virtually all able-bodied men of draft age - about 12 million - were needed to defend the republic. In short the draft was fair because virtually everybody that could serve had to serve. But those moments are rare. Imposing a draft at any other time creates not shared sacrifice, but a lottery for the unlucky"(Carafano) James Judge, a career counselor in Washington, D. C., decided to enlighten